Orange Book Club

Orange Book Club is a reading group to share views on award-winning or highly-acclaimed contemporary literary fiction.

Monday, December 04, 2006

John Banville's 'The Sea'

Afterthoughts

Max puts everything into historical present - his present life lives on the memories of his childhood. His childhood love, fantasies, knowledge, trauma moulded his life after - his adulthood, and way past that. I perserved right to the end to savour the sweetness of the book. The question is - do we try to relive our unfulfilled past in our present, only to realise that we can never find our loss nor the answers we need?

Banville's an excellent stylist who fits together with elegance the jigsaw pieces of life to complete the whole picture of it at the end.

My rating: ***1/2 (**** for the ending)
Award: The Man Booker Prize for Fiction 2005

-------------------------------------------------

Fav quotes
John Banville, The Sea, Picador, London, 2005.

'Was I too lazy, too inattentive, too self-absorbed? Yes, all of those things, and yet I cannot think it is a matter of blame, this forgetting, this not-having-known. I fancy, rather, that I expected too much, in the way of knowing. I know so little of myself, how should I think to know another?' p.215

-------------------------------------------------

Resources

www.themanbookerprize.com/

Available in major bookstores, NLB libraries, and SP library.

Friday, November 17, 2006

'Carry Me Down' by M.J. Hyland

Afterthoughts

Speaking from the first person's point of view, i.e. the adolescent protagonist - John, the novel serves as mirror into the protagonist's mind, a mind so sensitive, observant and meticulous. The language is plain and the text is like a report, which allows us to piece things up to read a child's mind and see the truthfulness or lies of adults. Does this world seek to live on the grey n sweep things under the carpet for the 'peace' and 'happiness' of the others?

Questions flood my mind:

- Can we take the truth?
- Would we rather be deluded?
- Is ignorance really a bliss?
- Do we live a double life?
- Do lies exist to reduce the hurt of the truth?
- Does one lie lead to another, creating a vicious cycle?
- Are we cowards?
- Are we trained to be good liars cos our parents are?
- Do white and black lies bear the same consequences?
- Is telling half-truths as good as lying?

My rating: ****
Award Mention: The Man Booker Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2006.

-------------------------------------------------------

My Favourite Quotes
MJ Hyland, Carry Me Down, Canongate, Edinburgh, 2006.

'...It's the kind of lie many people would call a white lie. But it's still a lie and it's told to benefit one and deceive another. Perhaps white lie don't work in the same way because the person telling them doesn't feel as anxious or troubled. And yet a white lie could have consequences just as awful as a black lie.' - p.55

'...This is not a soap opera where people blurt things out whenever they feel the urge.' - p.276

'Look at you. An eleven-year-old in the body of a grown man who insists on the ridiculous truth and who has got into a bad habit of lying.' - p.281

'Well, John, many people who claim to have this ability to detect lies have exremely irritable mothers, or alcoholic fathers, or some other force or presence in their early life that is, or was, unhealthy, unnatural, unpleasant, or extremely upsetting in some way...' - p.297

------------------------------------------------------------

Resources

http://www.themanbookerprize.com/2006prize/shortlist

Available in NLB libraries, SP library, and major bookstores

Monday, November 13, 2006

'The Secret River' by Kate Grenville

My Afterthoughts

A book that opens up the world I once stayed in - NSW, Australia. I enjoyed the book so much that I had to complete it in less than a week (record-breaking for me)! ;)

Taking the stand of a settler, William Thornhill, the story unveils the thoughts n dilemma a Brit convict was caught in - between life and death, between conscience and greed(survival?), between lordship and civilisation, between family and self, between order and dominance, between right and wrong. Do we justify our gains at the expense of others and/or out of our fear?

The first few pages remind me of Conrad's 'Heart of Darkness'. I certainly enjoy that familiar tone and style of a nice, classical novel.

I like the novel as it speaks from various angles through the eyes of the protagonist, Thornhill, an anti-hero.

My rating: ****
Award Mention: The Man Booker Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2006, Commonwealth Writer's Prize 2006.

---------------------------------------------------------

Unforgettable Quotes
Kate Grenville, The Secret River, Canongate Books, Edinburgh, 2006.

'How could he say, I am sorry that what I want more than anything is your prison?' p.156

'See, them yams grow where you putting in the corn, he said. You dig them up, means they go hungry.' p.174

'He had thought then that it was all part of the price a boy paid for getting by in the world. It seemed that a man had to go on paying.' p.180

'How had his life funnelled down to this corner, in which he had so little choice? His life had funnelled down once before, in Newgate, into the dead-end of the condemned cell. But the thing that lay ahead of him there had been out of his hands. There was a kind of innocence in waiting for Mr Executioner.

The difference with this was that he was choosing it, of his own free will.

The noose would have ended his life, but what he was about to do would end it too. Whichever choice he made, his life would not go on as it had before...' p.314

'But there was an emptiness as he watched Jack's hand caressing the dirt. This was something he did not have: a place that was part of his flesh and spirit. There was no part of the world he would keep coming back to, the way Jack did, just to feel it under him.' p.344

---------------------------------------------------------

Resources

Award mention:

Commonwealth Writer's Prize 2006
http://www.commonwealthfoundation.com/culturediversity/writersprize/

The Man Booker Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2006
http://www.themanbookerprize.com/pressoffice/release.php?r=27#titletop

Available in NLB libraries, SP library, and major bookstores

Sunday, November 12, 2006

'SQ21-Singapore Queer of the 21st Century' by Ng Yi-Sheng

My Afterthoughts

No, it's not another 'gay book' or some sob, sob story. And it's not there to change your lifestyle. But it's there to change your point of view on people in this community, a marginalized minority group. SQ21 is a collection of 15 stories - a celebration of life and love. Love of the forms you and I know - between parents and children, among siblings, between good friends, and of course, between 2 people of the same gender. Written in different styles but in the familiar Singapore English [not Singlish], it opens our eyes, hearts and minds to know people. I love the collection - some stories are heart-wrenching, most, heartwarming. We can all share and identify with the struggles told. After all, emotions are universal. And so is love.

My rating: ****
Mention: Non-Fiction Bestseller in major bookstores

-------------------------------

Resources


sq21.blogspot.com

Available in major bookstores and libraries.

Wednesday, October 18, 2006

'Oryx and Crake' by Margaret Atwood

Afterthoughts ~ 27 Oct 2006

Jimmy, aka Snowman, lives in a futuristic world where dreams come true with money and values are non-existant. And the fittest n smartest wants to rule the world in the name of peace and order, whereby sex is only for the innocent purposes of creation and procreation. Would the new world be any better?

I feel deeply about this book. It's a distant future which we can all identify with now. Thrilling and a page-turner, though I expected more from the ending. Still, it's a good read.

My rating for this book: ****
Awards: Man Booker Prize Shortlist 2003; Orange Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2004

-------------------------------------------------------------------
Unforgettable Quotes
[taken from Margaret Atwood, Oryx and Crake, Virago Press, London, 2004.]

"They had to be burned," he said, "to keep it from spreading."...
"What from spreading?"
"The disease." ...
"If I have a cough, will I be burned up?"
"Most likely," said his father, turning over the page.
- p.22, Oryx and Crake

P.S., she'd said. I have taken Killer with me to liberate her, as I know she will be happier living a wild, free life in the forest.- p. 69, Oryx and Crake

'This was how Jimmy first encountered Shakespeare - through Anna K.'s rendition of Macbeth.

Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow.
Creeps in this petty pace from day to day,
To the last syllable of recorded time;
And all our yesterdays have lighted fools
The way to dusty death,
...'
- p.97, Oryx and Crake

"As a species we're doomed by hope, then?"
"You could call it hope. That, or desperation."
"But we're doomed without hope, as well," said Jimmy.
"Only as individuals," said Crake cheerfully.
"Well, it sucks."
"Jimmy, grow up."
- p.139, Oryx and Crake

"You can't buy it, but it has a price," said Oryx. "Everything has a price."
- p.163, Oryx and Crake

Crake still had a collection of fridge magnets, but they were different notes. No more science quips.

Where God is, Man is not.
There are two moons, the one you can see and the one you can't.
Du musz dein Leben andern.
We understand more than we know.
I think, therefore.
To stay human is to break a limitation.
Dreams steals from its lair towards its prey.
- p.354, Oryx and Crake

"Immortality," said Crake, "is a concept. If you take 'mortality' as being, not death, but the foreknowledge of it and the fear of it, then 'immortality' is the absence of such fear. Babies are immortal. Edit out the fear, and you'll be.."
-p.356, Oryx and Crake

... Crake said once, "Would you kill someone you loved to spare them pain?"
- p.375, Oryx and Crake

"Change can be accommodated by any system depending on its rate," Crake used to say. "Touch your head to a wall, nothing happens, but if the same head hits the same wall at ninety miles an hour, it's red paint. We're in a speed tunnel, Jimmy. When the water's moving faster than the boat, you can't control a thing."
- p.398, Oryx and Crake

They noticed the remains of Crake lying on the ground, but as they had never seen Crake when alive, they believed Snowman when he told them this was thing of no importance - only a sort of husk, only a sort of pod. It would have been a shock to them to have witnessed their creator in his present state.
- p.410, Oryx and Crake

-------------------------------------------------------

Resources

Award Mention:
http://www.orangeprize.co.uk/opf/books.php4?bookid=158

Book Site:
http://www.randomhouse.com/features/atwood/oryxandcrake/rg.html

Available in:
NLB libraries, SP Main Library, major bookstores.

Sunday, October 15, 2006

'The History of Love' by Nicole Krauss

Afterthoughts

A genre of its kind to unravel the mystery of a long lost love sealed in a brown paper bag of manuscripts that lives, gets lost, is found and then drifts through decades. Served in light-hearted language, peppered with its namesake, love, the prose gives this tingling feeling of thrill as the characters try hard to piece up the jigsaw of their relationships and amend their past through the History of Love.

The title could be deemed as passe but its content is no trash. I like it for its simple yet complex portray of its ordinary characters. No matter how The History of Love undergoes the ages, the changes of names & places, it lives through and stays true to its root. Love.

My rating for this book: ***1/2
Award Mention: British Book Award 2006 (Richard & Judy's Book Club); Orange Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2006

------------------------------------------

The Reason to Quote

'I was named after every girl in a book called The History of Love.'(Alma)

and many other interesting ones I can't name offhand.

Nicole Krauss, The History of Love

------------------------------------------

Resources

Award Mention
www.orangeprize.co.uk/opf/shortlist.php4?bookid=190

Available in NLB libraries, SP library, and major bookstores

Saturday, September 16, 2006

Recent Read Books (Jun-Aug)

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

About cloned teenagers and their sense of loss and identity. Gripping and compeling in a simple langauge.

My rating: **** [Chris' Fav!]
Award Mention: The Man Booker Prize for Fiction Shortlist 2005

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

A Pale View of Hills by Kazuo Ishiguro

On the afterthoughts and reflection of a Japanese woman shaped and hurt by her past in the War. A dilemma we can all share.

My rating: ***1/2
Award Mention: Winifred Holtby Prize of the Royal Society of Literature, 1982

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

A Long Way Down by Nick Hornby

4 different voices that speak of their journey together - from almost suicide to the decision of self-reconciliation. An interesting and humorous read.

My rating: ***1/2
Award Mention: Costa Novel Award (formerly Whitebread Book Award) Shortlist 2005

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Specimen Days by Michael Cunningham

3 stories linked by 2 protagonists whose lives interwined. The stories bring out questions on the meaning of life and us thro interesting encounters of the protagonists living in the past, present and future.

Elegance infused in the page-turning adventures and journeys of life.

My rating: **** [Chris' Fav!]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Available in NLB libraries, SP library, and major bookstores

'We Need To Talk About Kevin' by Lionel Shriver

AfterThoughts

It's a v powerful, gripping, intriguing, moving, mind-blowing story that speaks to me. I was Kevin, I was Eva... I dun have to be a highschool killer or a mother to feel n relate to it. Kevin is a mirror of Eva that speaks aloud. He is aloofness, alertness, defensiveness, self-righteousness, pride n arrogance, all roll into one. It's a high price to pay, but is it too late? And does it take death to know life, to know ourselves?

It was somewhat long-drawn for me to chew n savour on the thick book, like a rubbery beef or something, but it oozed out a flavour of its own, so distinct that I felt it was worth the process. Yes, I was literally counting the pages, but I made it n loved it! ;p

Rating range: * ~ ****
My Rating for this book: **** [Chris' Fav!]
Award/s: Orange Prize for Fiction 2005
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unforgettable quotes

'Know what they do with cats, don't you. They do it in the house, and you shove their faces into their own shit. They don't like it. They use the box.' p.204

'I used to think I knew,' he said glumly. 'Now I'm not so sure.' p.464

Lionel Shriver, We Need To Talk About Kevin
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Resources

Award Mention
www.orangeprize.co.uk/opf/archive.php4

Reading Group Guide
www.readinggroupguides.com/guides3/we_need_talk_kevin1.asp

Available in NLB libraries, major bookstores